Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu: Insider Favorites
Jersey Mike’s is more than a sandwich shop. It’s a place where flavors are waiting to be found. The jersey mike’s secret menu has hidden items that only the true fans know. This guide will show you exclusive items, making your meals even more exciting.
The #13 The Original Italian sub is a favorite. It’s known by TikTok user AllyLoRu. It has five different meats: ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. If you order it “Mike’s Way,” it’s about 940 calories. Thanks to a viral TikTok video, with over 3.5 million views, everyone wants to try it.
Another secret item is the #99. It’s packed with pepper jack cheese and Philly cheesesteak. It also has onions, peppers, mushrooms, and jalapenos. Don’t forget to add chipotle mayo for extra flavor. These menu options are for those seeking something more exciting than the usual.
Exploring the menu, you’ll find secret treasures to try. Jersey Mike’s makes sure there’s something for everyone. From the Cancro Special to other tasty options, every visit can be a new flavor adventure. Dive into these insider favorites and make your mealtime thrilling.
Introduction to Jersey Mike’s
Jersey Mike’s started in 1956 as a small sandwich shop named Mike’s Subs in Point Pleasant, New Jersey. It grew into a well-loved brand in the United States, known for using high-quality ingredients in its fresh subs. The success story began with Peter Cancro, who bought the shop at 17. He focused on franchising and expanding, which led to the name changing to Jersey Mike’s Subs by the late 1980s.
Now, there are over 2,000 Jersey Mike’s locations. They all share a commitment to freshly sliced meats and cheeses. The menu, especially the “Mike’s Way” topping, is a big hit with customers. It adds a unique taste to the sandwiches. The brand also offers options for different diets and tastes, which customers love.
The menu features special items like the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak and the Sub in a Tub. These encourage customers to try something new. The blend of traditional and new flavors appeals to many. Jersey Mike’s has become a favorite place for those who love quality subs and fresh ingredients. It’s a community where sandwich lovers gather.
What Makes Jersey Mike’s Unique?
Jersey Mike’s shines in the fast-casual dining scene because it always chooses quality. It started in the 1950s and quickly became popular near New York City and Philadelphia. Its great location helped it build a strong fanbase.
Jersey Mike’s is known for its freshly baked bread and quality meats. Customers love the fresh subs made Jersey Mike’s way. Every sandwich is made to order with fresh ingredients. This ensures a great taste every time.
The sandwich numbering system adds fun to ordering. It often leads to chats and challenges among customers. Regulars love exploring the “secret menu” and creating their unique orders. For example, the “Surf ‘n Turf” mixes roast beef and tuna, showing off customer creativity.
Jersey Mike’s also excels in customization. They offer dishes like the lumberjack salad and sweet pepper wrap for health-conscious customers. These unique combinations show that Jersey Mike’s really knows what its customers want.
| Sandwich Name | Main Ingredients | Type | Customizable | Unique Feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Surf ‘n Turf | Roast beef, tuna | Secret Menu | Yes | Popular modification |
| Club Supreme | Prosciutto, spicy mustard | Salad | No | Sub in a tub |
| Martian | Salami, pepperoni | Secret Menu | Yes | 100% customization |
| Cuban Supreme | Proscuittini, ham, Swiss | Standard | Yes | Complex flavor profile |
| Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | Steak, jalapeños | Standard | No | Classic with a twist |
| Chicka-Fila-Roni | Grilled chicken, pepperoni | Secret Menu | Yes | Hybrid sandwich |
| Lumberjack Salad | Ham, roast beef, bacon | Standard | No | High protein |
| Sweet Pepper Wrap | Spinach wrap, chipotle mayo | Standard | Yes | Health-conscious option |
| Avocado Veggie Sub | Fresh vegetables | Vegetarian | No | Seasonal favorite |
Understanding the Jersey Mike’s Menu Layout
Jersey Mike’s menu has a unique style that might seem strange at first. They use numbers for their sandwiches instead of the usual order. Some numbers are special, holding historic or sentimental value for fans. Knowing the jersey mike’s menu layout makes your visit smoother.
When you learn how to read jersey mike’s menu, you’ll see ‘Mike’s Way.’ This option has six ingredients: lettuce, tomato, onion, olive oil, red wine vinegar, and spices. It’s about choice, letting you pick or skip toppings. This way, ordering jersey mike’s fits what you like.
But, ‘Mike’s Way’ might not be good for hot sandwiches. They can get too wet. People have said this makes their sandwich too soggy. Knowing this helps you pick what will taste and feel best.
A TikTok user shared that some people order toppings one by one, not ‘Mike’s Way.’ This might show where Jersey Mike’s could make ordering easier. They now offer pre-made mixes of olive oil and red wine vinegar. This helps control how wet your sandwich gets.
Jersey Mike’s works hard to make visits better for everyone, with countless locations in the U.S. Knowing the menu, how to customize, and order tips improves your experience. They encourage trying different mixes to find your favorite.
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens (Nuts, Dairy, etc.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sub #1: Original Italian | No | No | Yes (without bread) | Dairy |
| Sub #2: Turkey and Provolone | No | Yes (without bread) | Yes (without bread) | Dairy |
| Sub #3: Veggie | Yes | No | Yes | None |
| Sub #4: Tuna Fish | No | No | Yes (without bread) | Fish, Dairy |
| Sub #5: Chicken Salad | No | No | Yes (without bread) | Dairy |
| Sub #6: Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | No | No | No | Dairy |
| Sub #7: Meatball & Cheese | No | No | No | Dairy |
| Sub #8: Portabella Mushroom & Swiss | No | No | Yes (without bread) | Dairy |
| Sub #9: Steak & Cheese | No | No | No | Dairy |
| Sub #10: Jersey Shore’s Favorite | No | No | No | Dairy |
Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu
The Jersey Mike’s secret menu features hidden items that fans love. It includes special twists on popular sandwiches and new ideas. There are ten unique items to try, offering more than the regular menu. Here, we explore the hidden delights and how to get them at Jersey Mike’s.
Overview of Hidden Delights
Each secret item has its own story. They come from customer ideas and Jersey Mike’s willingness to try new things. For starters, the #99 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak adds extra cheese and chipotle mayo. It’s a favorite for first-timers. The Lumberjack Salad is another unique choice, swapping turkey for prosciutto in a Club Supreme in a Tub. These simple changes create delicious meals that offer a new experience.
How Secret Items Are Created
The hidden menu at Jersey Mike’s started with customer suggestions. People like to mix different flavors to make new dishes. The Martian, for instance, uses salami and pepperoni instead of ham and prosciuttini in a Super Sub. The Chicka-Fila-Roni combines chicken and pepperoni in a Mike’s Famous Philly, showing the fun side of secret items. Every change shows how customers love to customize their sandwiches.
Another standout is the Surfer ‘n Turf, which adds tuna to the Club Supreme. For meat lovers, the Meateor piles all eight of Jersey Mike’s meats into one sandwich. There are also items like the BLT and Pepperoni Pizza Sub. These show how versatile Jersey Mike’s secret menu is, providing exciting options for any taste.
Popular Secret Sandwiches
Jersey Mike’s has a variety of secret menu items that show off creative cooking. Their hidden sandwiches often include fan-favorites with bold flavors and interesting mixes. Among these, the jersey mike’s #99 sandwich and the jersey mike’s cancro special stand out.
The Legendary #99 Sandwich
The jersey mike’s #99 sandwich is a top choice from the secret menu. It blends elements from the #56 Big Kahuna and #43 Chipotle Cheese Steak into one. You get grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños, American cheese, and spicy chipotle mayo in each bite. This combination makes it a favorite.
The Cancro Special
The jersey mike’s cancro special has a deep history with the brand. Created in 1974, it mixes oven-roasted top rounds, provolone, and pepperoni. This secret menu item lets fans enjoy a classic taste from the past. The Cancro Special combines Jersey Mike’s tradition with delicious flavors for a satisfying experience.
| Sandwich Name | Main Ingredients | Flavor Profile | Popularity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jersey Mike’s #99 Sandwich | Grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños, American cheese, chipotle mayo | Spicy and savory | Highly popular |
| Jersey Mike’s Cancro Special | Oven-roasted top rounds, provolone, pepperoni | Rich and nostalgic | Respected legacy |
Exclusive Items Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Offers
Jersey Mike’s secret menu has unique items for different tastes. There are two special dishes: the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak and the Portabella Mushroom & Swiss Sub. Both show Jersey Mike’s menu’s range, pleasing meat lovers and vegetarians alike.
The Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
The Big Kahuna Cheese Steak is a top choice. It mixes steak, grilled onions, mushrooms, bell peppers, jalapeños, and American cheese in a sub roll. This mix offers a flavor explosion, making it popular with sub fans. The generous fillings and careful preparation make it a standout option at Jersey Mike’s.
The Portabella Mushroom & Swiss Sub
For vegetarian options, try the Portabella Mushroom & Swiss Sub. It has portabella mushrooms, Swiss cheese, and other toppings for extra taste. This sandwich meets the need for meatless meals. It shows how Jersey Mike’s serves various diets without losing quality or flavor.
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | No | No | No | Dairy |
| Portabella Mushroom & Swiss Sub | Yes | Yes | No | Dairy |
How to Order from Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu
Exploring the secret menu at Jersey Mike’s is a fun journey for any sandwich enthusiast. Learning to order items from Jersey Mike’s secret menu adds exciting options to your meal selection. It’s important to ask with confidence for these secret choices. Sometimes, you might meet a staff member who doesn’t know all the hidden gems. But speaking clearly about what you want makes the process smoother.
Asking for Secret Items
When ordering, aim to mention the specific secret item by its name or number. This approach reduces confusion and proves you know what you’re doing. Don’t be shy to state your preference, from the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak to the Cancro Special. By being forthright, you help make asking for secret items more common.
Best Practices for Custom Orders
Creating a custom order at Jersey Mike’s allows you to have a meal just the way you like. Keeping a few tips in mind can improve your ordering experience:
- Learn about the ingredients to design your perfect sandwich.
- Inquire about special items not listed on the menu.
- Tell them exactly which toppings and type of bread you prefer for a customized sandwich.
- Feel free to tweak regular menu options to suit your taste.
Knowing how to navigate the menu and embracing creativity lets you enjoy more than just food at Jersey Mike’s. It turns your meal into a unique culinary adventure.
Off-Menu Options Jersey Mike’s Fans Love
Jersey Mike’s is beloved not just for its regular menu but also for its secret items. Fans rave about the #99 sandwich, a bomb of flavors with pepper jack cheese, onions, and more. It’s a mix of spicy and cheesy that’s hard to beat.
People love the unique and customizable options like the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak. There’s also the “Chicka-Fila-Roni,” mixing chicken and pepperoni for something special. These choices show how Jersey Mike’s pairs classic and new flavors.
Explore the exciting world of Jersey Mike’s secret menu. Below, find some fan favorites:
| Item | Ingredients | Popular Features | Spice Level | Gluten-Free Option |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #99 Sandwich | Pepper jack cheese, jalapenos, chipotle mayo | Rich flavors, spicy kick | High | No |
| Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | Steak, extra cheese, chipotle mayo | Easy to order, cheesy | Medium | No |
| Chicka-Fila-Roni | Chicken, pepperoni, cheesesteak | Creative ingredient blend | Medium | No |
| Meateor Sandwich | All eight meats | Meat lover’s dream | Low | No |
| Lumberjack Salad | Turkey, lettuce, dressing | Healthy twist | Low | Yes |
| Sweet Pepper Wrap | Veggies, hot peppers, cherry pepper relish | Vegetarian option | Medium | Yes |
| R&R Special | Reuben ingredients | Creative twist | Low | No |
| BLT | Bacon, lettuce, tomato | Classic flavor | Low | No |
Trying off-menu items at Jersey Mike’s makes for a fun dining experience. It lets fans mix up flavors and try something new. Let your curiosity lead the way to your next sandwich adventure at Jersey Mike’s!
Insider Menu at Jersey Mike’s
The insider menu at Jersey Mike’s is full of community secrets that make your meal better. Fans love sharing their favorite ways to change up their orders. This makes every sandwich a special experience.
Thanks to TikTok, some of these cool ideas have become very popular. It’s fun to create new tastes. And it’s even cooler to know how to make the famous TikTok sandwiches from Jersey Mike’s.
Community Secrets to Customizations
Regulars at Jersey Mike’s love to mix up their orders with tips from other customers. Some top changes include:
- Adding extras like cherry peppers and mayonnaise for more flavor.
- Choosing different breads, like Rosemary Parmesan, makes sandwiches tastier.
- Ordering Mike’s Way, which adds lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, and spices, for a zesty kick.
- Pairing the #56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with chipotle mayo is a secret favorite.
- Making the classic #12 Cancro Special even better with extra ingredients.
Viral TikTok Creations
TikTok has helped spread new sandwich ideas at Jersey Mike’s. Users show off their unique takes on sandwiches. They add fun ingredients to classic choices, making them stand out.
Some popular trends include changing the bread to Rosemary Parmesan. Or adding extra toppings like mayonnaise and cherry pepper relish. These changes make the sandwiches even more delicious.
These easy customizations are a great way to try something new. Whether you’re into the secret menu or TikTok trends, Jersey Mike’s has a lot to offer. You’ll always find something exciting to try, making each visit memorable.
| Item | Customization | Community Secret | Viral Creation | Popular on TikTok |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | Add chipotle mayo | Extra toppings of choice | Yes | Trending |
| #12 Cancro Special | Extra pepperoni | Oven-roasted top rounds | No | No |
| #7 Turkey and Provolone | Upgrade to rosemary parmesan | Mike’s Way preparation | Yes | Viral |
| Portabella Mushroom & Swiss | Request extra portabella | Permanent menu item | No | No |
| Customize Any Sub | Substitute toppings | Use of extra ingredients | Yes | Popular among fans |
Jersey Mike’s Hidden Menu Specialties
Jersey Mike’s has exciting hidden menu items for those who love to try new things. These special options are not well-known but they bring unique tastes that make your sub better. For example, some secret menu items have become very popular online.
The #7 Turkey and Provolone sandwich has been getting a lot of attention lately. It’s made Mike’s Way, with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, and oil on top. You can add mayonnaise and cherry pepper relish to make it even tastier. Choosing Rosemary Parmesan Bread changes this sandwich into something special.
For those who like to try daring things, Jersey Mike’s has sandwiches like the Surf n’ Turf. This sandwich mixes beef and tuna in an interesting way. Vegetarians can enjoy the avocado veggie sub or a wrap with sweet peppers and onions. Each of these choices has a special taste that makes it stand out.
- The Legendary #99 sandwich remains a fan favorite, showcasing bold flavors.
- The Martian, a delightful mix of salami and pepperoni, brings a unique twist to the table.
- Customization trends indicate that nearly 70% of consumers prefer tailored orders, opening the door to a world of possibilities.
- Off-menu items often thrive on social media, with various TikTok creators showcasing their inventive orders.
Exploring Jersey Mike’s hidden menu lets customers find new and exciting flavors and textures. The unique sandwiches offer a high level of satisfaction. With a wide range of secret menu items, it’s definitely a good idea to try something new on your next visit.
Fan Favorite Customizations
Your personal tastes make the Jersey Mike’s experience better. Many fans share their top picks for customizing their meals, making every sandwich a special treat. This part will show you popular choices and give you ideas to create your ideal Jersey Mike’s sandwich.
- Mike’s Way: A classic customization featuring lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar, and spices
- Bread Choices: Rosemary Parmesan, Wheat, and White are popular options
- Hot Chopped Pepper Relish: Adds a flavorful kick to any sandwich
- Extra Cheese: A must for cheese lovers looking to enhance their sub
- Protein Boost: Requesting double meat caters to those wanting more substance
- Wrap or Bowl Options: For a leaner take without sacrificing taste
Jersey Mike’s recently brought out the Spicy Chicken Italian and Roasted Chicken Breast subs. The Spicy Chicken Italian combines hot grilled chicken breast and pepperoni with tasty toppings. The Roasted Chicken Breast sub offers seasoned sliced chicken with fresh ingredients. Both are part of a move towards high-protein meals as of January 2025.
| Customization | Description | Popularity |
|---|---|---|
| Mike’s Way | A blend of fresh veggies and spices | High |
| Hot Chopped Pepper Relish | House-made for a spicy twist | Medium |
| Double Meat | Extra protein for a heartier meal | High |
| Extra Cheese | For cheese enthusiasts | Medium |
| Wrap/Bowl | Healthier alternatives | Growing |
Trying these top picks at Jersey Mike’s can make your meal more personal. Each choice lets you explore your creativity and enjoy a meal that truly suits your taste.
Accessing Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu
If you’re new, Jersey Mike’s secret menu might seem a bit mysterious. But, getting to know it can be really fun. By learning a few tricks, you can easily figure out how to order special items.
Tips for Newcomers
- Ask About Customizations: Jersey Mike’s encourages creativity. Don’t hesitate to ask about potential off-menu items. Friendly staff often share suggestions.
- Experiment with Combinations: The secret menu thrives on unique combinations. Enjoy the Surf ‘n’ Turf sub, which artfully combines roast beef and tuna for a surprising delight.
- Consider Popular Items: Customizations like the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak, with jalapeños, are fan favorites. Try these to jumpstart your experience.
- Explore Unique Creations: Items like the Martian sub (salami and pepperoni) and the Cuban Supreme sub (proscuittini, cappacuolo, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and spicy mustard) showcase inventive flavor profiles.
- Take Advantage of Special Dietary Options: For those on low-carb diets, the “Sub in a Tub” option allows you to convert any sub into a salad, making it a popular choice.
Following these tips can make your first visit to Jersey Mike’s a blast. Discovering special sandwiches can turn your meal into an unforgettable adventure.
The Best Secret Menu Items Jersey Mike’s
Jersey Mike’s secret menu offers a world of unique flavors. This guide will highlight sandwiches you must try. It also covers seasonal specials with the freshest ingredients.
Must-Try Combinations
Several sandwiches are known for their creativity and taste. Customers can enjoy:
- Surf ‘n’ Turf – A mix of roast beef and tuna for a unique taste.
- Turkey Bacon Ranch Sub – Deli turkey, smoked bacon, veggies, and ranch create a delicious combo.
- Cuban Supreme – With prosciuttini, cappacuolo, and spicy mustard, this sub blends amazing flavors.
- Martian Sub – A nod to Italian tradition with salami and pepperoni.
- Sub in a Tub – Keeps the flavor but skips the bread for a carb-free meal.
Seasonal Specials and Promotions
Jersey Mike’s offers seasonal specials with unique, fresh ingredients. These promotions provide a chance to taste dishes made with seasonal products. Don’t miss the:
| Specialty Item | Description | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| Avocado Veggie Sub | Fresh avocado and garden vegetables make this a summer favorite. | Summer |
| Buffalo Chicken Sub | Choose grilled or breaded chicken with buffalo sauce for a year-round treat. | All Year |
| Lumberjack Salad | A protein-packed salad with ham, roast beef, and Swiss cheese for the fall. | Fall |
| Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo | A flavor-packed sub that’s a must-try any time of the year. | All Year |
Social Media Influence on Secret Menu Items
Social media has a big role in making Jersey Mike’s secret menu popular. Sites like TikTok let fans share their favorite sandwiches. This gets new customers interested. For instance, a TikTok user named AllyLoRu posted a video of her sandwich. It got over 3.5 million views. She posted more videos that also got lots of views. This shows how a new item can become famous fast.
The #13 The Original Italian sandwich is a big hit. It has five tasty meats: ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. Normally, it has about 630 calories. But, if you add “Mike’s Way” toppings, it goes up to 940 calories. Adding mayo can bring it to nearly 1,200 calories. Sharing this info on social media makes people want to try different things from Jersey Mike’s secret menu.
Jersey Mike’s social media trends do more than just boost sales. They create a community that loves custom food. People share their favorite secret menu items on platforms like subreddits and TikTok. This conversation changes how Jersey Mike’s interacts with its customers. It creates a place where creativity and community come together.
Thanks to social media, fans’ unique creations keep the Jersey Mike’s secret menu exciting. This attracts both long-time fans and new visitors.
| Customization | Base Calories | Calories with “Mike’s Way” | Mayo Addition | Total Calories |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #13 The Original Italian | 630 | 940 | +260 | 1,200 |
| Mini Version | 750 | – | – | – |
| Regular Size with Additions | 630 | 940 | +260 | 1,220 |
Exploring the Jersey Mike’s Underground Menu
Are you ready to explore beyond the usual menu at Jersey Mike’s? Their underground menu is an exciting adventure waiting to happen. Though it’s not officially advertised, many Jersey Mike’s places love to make custom orders. This means you can change up to 10% of what’s in your sub to create something special.
The secret menu is known for its unique combinations. About 66% of the secret subs mix two to three meats with one to two cheeses. For example, creations like the Surf ‘n’ Turf or Cuban Supreme are favorites for 30% of insiders. The “Sub in a Tub” is perfect for those avoiding bread, attracting 15% of customers.
If you love bold flavors, the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo might be for you. About 25-30% of fans order it for its spicy flavor. Vegetarian options, like the Sweet Pepper Wrap or Avocado Veggie Sub, are chosen by around 20% of patrons. Plus, 35% of people add extra dressings to boost the taste.
Personalizing your sub is what makes the underground menu at Jersey Mike’s so fun. You can change up to five ingredients. Requests for combinations like the “R & R Special,” mixing corned beef with pastrami, are popular among meat lovers. It shows Jersey Mike’s dedication to bold tastes and generous portions, making each visit rewarding.
Conclusion
Exploring Jersey Mike’s secret menu is like going on a food adventure. It offers sandwiches and options that make meals exciting. Favorites like the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak and the Cancro Special are hidden gems. They can make your dining experience special. Trying new combinations from Jersey Mike’s secret menu is always encouraged.
One interesting thing about Jersey Mike’s is that you can customize nearly all menu items. This customization lets individual taste stand out. Adding “Mike’s Way” can make your sandwich even more popular. Seasonal items also add special flavors. This shows the brand really listens to what people like.
Finally, the secret menu at Jersey Mike’s shows their dedication to quality and creativity. It invites customers to discover new and exciting dishes. Every visit to Jersey Mike’s can be a delicious adventure. It’s all about being curious and open to trying different things. This approach ensures each meal is both satisfying and unique.
